Stephen Boocks
  • Home
  • Portfolio
    • Current Work
    • Tetris & Scores
    • Early Dots
    • No Objects 2012-2013
    • Objects 2011-2012
  • Bio/Statements
  • Resume
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Curates
  • Blog

Everyone's a Critic

9/10/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Isn't it great that art exhibitions are not generally rated on some number or star system- whether 1 to 5, 1 to 10 or the classic 100 point scale we all remember from school. Imagine if your show only scored "three paintbrushes" in Artforum. There's a great line from Lou Reed on Take No Prisoners that goes something like, "imagine working for a year on an album and some asshole from the Village Voice gives you a B+."

Ratings play a big part in my day job working in the wine world. Everyone wants that 90 point wine that only costs $10. I have this "terrible" job that requires me taste well over a thousand wines a year and yes, I give each one a score. Every wine writer will tell you that a score is just a guide and you need to read the actual review to get a better feeling about whether or not the wine is a good choice for you. Since my scores are not published and are only used either as part of a group analysis to determine what wines we should carry or for my own reference, I tend to be somewhat generous on nice pleasant wines, giving 90 points to wines that I know most writes would score 86-88 points. The longer I've been at the wine game, I have also stopped giving an absolute score. I prefer to say a wine is 88-90 points or 91-92. The publications want a more absolute view of quality so a delicious wine will lose points because its not very complex or the finish isn't long enough. I tend to score wines that I want to buy and drink a little higher simply because I like them. I am much more stingy in scoring wines over 90 points. These are more expensive wines so if I continue to consider if I would want to buy and drink the wine, its going to need to deliver exponentially more to score higher. The big question I get when I'm out in our stores helping customers is what is the difference between an 89 point wine and a 90 point wine. The answer is maybe a lot or maybe very little. Its one opinion from one sip on a random day.

I've been a music junkie since my early teens and have always rated albums for myself. Rolling Stone and other publications typically use a 5 star system but I find that scale a little limiting so I use my own 11 point system that allows half point increments. Pitchfork has a 10 point system but allows for tenth of a point increments such as 8.3. Isn't that really an 83 out of 100. My 11 point system is really a 10 point systems where you substitute an 11 for a 10. As with Nigel's amp in Spinal Tap, for me, these albums have that extra kick. There are only a handful of albums that I would give an 11: Kind of Blue (Miles Davis), Highway 61 Revisited (Dylan), In C (Terry Riley), Another Green World (Brian Eno), 3rd (Peter Gabriel), Remain in Light (Talking Heads), Kid A (Radiohead), Music for Airports (the Bang on a Can version of the Brian Eno piece). These albums are all perfect for me. Not a bad song or even part of a song. I can't imagine anything to make them better. There are hundreds of awesome albums that I would only give 9.5 because there is something that bugs me just a little. Something that I would change if I could. This is why I use that half point increment.

I've been deep diving into Brian Eno lately and started thinking if there is a better way to rate albums. I find initial impressions often change over time. Perhaps frequency of listening (rotations) is a better way to rate. I listen to Thursday Afternoon way more than I do Taking Tiger Mountain by Strategy, but is it better? There are tons of great albums like Neil Young's Tonight's the Night or Soft Machine's 3rd that I may not listen to very often at all for particular reasons.

I'm a bit of a cataloger and since these ratings are for myself, I guess it only matters if I know what the ratings mean.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Enthusiasms

    Ramblings about art, music, literature, food, beverages and other interests that generally affect my work in some way

    Archives

    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    April 2015
    December 2014
    June 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013

    Categories

    All
    General

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.